Resolve that is unenforceable Shareholder who challenged its implementation, the arbitration plastic drawers clause plastic drawers introduced by the Assembly on the Reform of the Bylaws
Today we bring readers an interesting case where a shareholder raised the annulment of decisions taken by majority, plastic drawers by an Assembly which amended the bylaws, introducing an arbitration clause to resolve conflicts intrasocietarios.
When the SA was sued by the dissenting shareholder, raises the plea that, based on the arbitration clause. The exception is rejected in both instances and Justice Commercial Jurisdiction, after confirming the Judgment of First Instance, arguing that always prevails the constitutional guarantee of natural judge and defense at trial and is unenforceable arbitration clause who challenged invalidity your implementation. plastic drawers
This issue was addressed in Autos captioned: "ESPARRICA MARIO ROBERTO c / FAMIQ SA s / REGULAR" (Reg 029620/2009.) - CNCom - SALA A- 11/10 / 2.01 1 published by elDial. plastic drawers com on the day of the date, 27/01/2012.
Room A of the National Court of Appeals in Commercial, composed of Judge Mrs. Dr. Isabel Míguez and Mr Justice Dr Alfredo Arturo Kölliker Frers decided to reject the appeal filed by the defendant company and confirm the decision appealed, imposing costs on the order caused attentive plastic drawers the particularities of the case and the law could be believed the appellant to act as he did (art. 68, para. 2 CPCCN).
(I) The Honor grade dismissed the objection of incompetence by the defendant company, due to be considered inapplicable to sub lite arbitral jurisdiction under the tenth seventh clause (17a) of the Bylaws of "Famiq SA" by According to the reform approved plastic drawers by the Shareholders of that society, on 15.04.09.- plastic drawers
(Ii) Judge held that while sharing the possibility of implementation, effectiveness and eventual virtuality of such conflicts mechanism, could not be overlooked plastic drawers that the scope of the institute should be judged as outstanding, this necessarily translating into a weighting restrictiva.-
(Iii) From that perspective he emphasized the need for the arbitral submission required plastic drawers the agreement of wills of those who would apply, can not be denied that the plaintiff, Mr. Esparrica, had not given his assent to the formula to solve proposal conflicts most SHAREHOLDERS
(Iv) referred in this regard, that the plaintiff plastic drawers had brought an action for annulment of the decisions taken by the Board and then by the Assembly, in two acts performed dated 11.03.09 and 15.04.09, and that among the disputed points are precisely met the statutory reform that introduced the arbitration clause in question.
(V) From this prism, the lower court judged that, being questioned the legitimacy of the above shareholders' resolutions, would be far less doubtful the current operation of the judicial extension proposed in the statutory reform, which is the subject of cuestionamiento.-
(I) "Cuadra begin by noting that the actor, Mario Roberto Esparrica, in his dual capacity as Director and Shareholder plastic drawers of the Company defendant" Famiq SA "chased in cars - among other things plastic drawers - the annulment of the decisions of the Assembly 15.04.09, among which is the statutory reform imposed an arbitration clause to resolve social conflicts that motivates this issue, to understand that in this way rights are meanwhile available merman. " plastic drawers
(Ii) "That being so, it should be emphasized that in almost unanimously, the doctrine characterizes the arbitration agreement as a contract that is subject, as such, the requirements of validity, as to consent to the capacity, the object and the cause requires the Civil Code. Therefore its content is entirely left to the will of the parties, who may agree on the arbitral jurisdiction over all litigation cases arising as a result of the substantial relationship which links or limit it to those relating to specific aspects of that relationship. "
(Iii) "In any case, however, since the obligation to compromise contained in the arbitration clause implies a waiver of the general principle of submission plastic drawers of disputes to Natural Judges must interpret the scope thereof restrictively." ( cfr. Palacio, L. "Civil Litigation", T. IX, page 40 et seq.)
(Iv) "From such a prism can not be ignored so that the arbitration court matter sometimient
Today we bring readers an interesting case where a shareholder raised the annulment of decisions taken by majority, plastic drawers by an Assembly which amended the bylaws, introducing an arbitration clause to resolve conflicts intrasocietarios.
When the SA was sued by the dissenting shareholder, raises the plea that, based on the arbitration clause. The exception is rejected in both instances and Justice Commercial Jurisdiction, after confirming the Judgment of First Instance, arguing that always prevails the constitutional guarantee of natural judge and defense at trial and is unenforceable arbitration clause who challenged invalidity your implementation. plastic drawers
This issue was addressed in Autos captioned: "ESPARRICA MARIO ROBERTO c / FAMIQ SA s / REGULAR" (Reg 029620/2009.) - CNCom - SALA A- 11/10 / 2.01 1 published by elDial. plastic drawers com on the day of the date, 27/01/2012.
Room A of the National Court of Appeals in Commercial, composed of Judge Mrs. Dr. Isabel Míguez and Mr Justice Dr Alfredo Arturo Kölliker Frers decided to reject the appeal filed by the defendant company and confirm the decision appealed, imposing costs on the order caused attentive plastic drawers the particularities of the case and the law could be believed the appellant to act as he did (art. 68, para. 2 CPCCN).
(I) The Honor grade dismissed the objection of incompetence by the defendant company, due to be considered inapplicable to sub lite arbitral jurisdiction under the tenth seventh clause (17a) of the Bylaws of "Famiq SA" by According to the reform approved plastic drawers by the Shareholders of that society, on 15.04.09.- plastic drawers
(Ii) Judge held that while sharing the possibility of implementation, effectiveness and eventual virtuality of such conflicts mechanism, could not be overlooked plastic drawers that the scope of the institute should be judged as outstanding, this necessarily translating into a weighting restrictiva.-
(Iii) From that perspective he emphasized the need for the arbitral submission required plastic drawers the agreement of wills of those who would apply, can not be denied that the plaintiff, Mr. Esparrica, had not given his assent to the formula to solve proposal conflicts most SHAREHOLDERS
(Iv) referred in this regard, that the plaintiff plastic drawers had brought an action for annulment of the decisions taken by the Board and then by the Assembly, in two acts performed dated 11.03.09 and 15.04.09, and that among the disputed points are precisely met the statutory reform that introduced the arbitration clause in question.
(V) From this prism, the lower court judged that, being questioned the legitimacy of the above shareholders' resolutions, would be far less doubtful the current operation of the judicial extension proposed in the statutory reform, which is the subject of cuestionamiento.-
(I) "Cuadra begin by noting that the actor, Mario Roberto Esparrica, in his dual capacity as Director and Shareholder plastic drawers of the Company defendant" Famiq SA "chased in cars - among other things plastic drawers - the annulment of the decisions of the Assembly 15.04.09, among which is the statutory reform imposed an arbitration clause to resolve social conflicts that motivates this issue, to understand that in this way rights are meanwhile available merman. " plastic drawers
(Ii) "That being so, it should be emphasized that in almost unanimously, the doctrine characterizes the arbitration agreement as a contract that is subject, as such, the requirements of validity, as to consent to the capacity, the object and the cause requires the Civil Code. Therefore its content is entirely left to the will of the parties, who may agree on the arbitral jurisdiction over all litigation cases arising as a result of the substantial relationship which links or limit it to those relating to specific aspects of that relationship. "
(Iii) "In any case, however, since the obligation to compromise contained in the arbitration clause implies a waiver of the general principle of submission plastic drawers of disputes to Natural Judges must interpret the scope thereof restrictively." ( cfr. Palacio, L. "Civil Litigation", T. IX, page 40 et seq.)
(Iv) "From such a prism can not be ignored so that the arbitration court matter sometimient
No comments:
Post a Comment